To be fair, Earthbound did take a critical and commercial pounding in 1995 when it first came out, often for those same reasons. I was honestly amazed that it developed the cult status it did after the fact, but I am glad that Nintendo at least includes it in SNES collections nowadays. The critical and commercial reception it got was upsetting to Nintendo Japan and the US localizer, Marcus Lindblom, who really put his all into the localizaiton, which was probably the best RPG localization out there at the time. Hopefully he's found satisfaction in seeing the game achieve cult status.
I have a bootleg cartridge version of Mother 3. My primary means of playing it is through the Game Boy Player for my Gamecube. Great game... but it makes me wish Nintendo had completed Mother 3 for the N64. Not only would that have fulfilled a yawning niche in the N64's library, but it's possible that it might have been more likely to be released over here, simply because Nintendo was more willing to take chance on Japan-only franchises in order to attract people back to the N64 and Gamecube - that's the environment that brought us Animal Crossing, Advance Wars, and Fire Emblem, after all.


